Slider Title


Our Story

Anthony’s On The Lake is about a passion for serving its customers’ fine food with amazing sunsets on the lake! Our waterfront restaurant has been through two generations serving the public for 45 years. We believe in fresh ingredients, and home-cooked food made like our parents would make all the time. So order our delicious food made with the finest fresh ingredients purchased locally and served locally.

Our staff is also committed to having our guests feel comfortable while dining during these times. We have gone through strict measures to ensure a COVID-19 cautionary environment and follow all the CDC and NYS COVID-19 Guidelines. We fog between seatings have cleaned and updated our ventilation system, have barriers between tables.  All of our tables are 6ft or more for your dining comfort.

Anthony Pellegrino
Owner and Chief Taster...


Enjoy dinner on the water with a fantastic view of the sunset on that lake!  Where you will enjoy meals prepared by our chefs made from the freshest of ingredients. Everything is made fresh and served professionally by our staff. We buy local and served local!



Our Chefs have put together weekly menus of your favorite comfort foods along with weekly infused specials with all of the tantalizing flavors that will leave you wanting more. There are dishes for everyone, including gluten free and vegetarian options.

Anthony's On The water

Pre Fixed Menu Uno

Sauteed PEI Mussels

red or white , w/thyme, garlic & oil


Baked Clams Arreganata

toasted breadcrumbs, olive oil, garlic scampi


Bruschetta & Spinach & Cheese

plum tomatoes, basil, garlic toast, e.v.o.o


Mozzarella with Prosciutto

fritta, pomodoro sauce or garlic dip


Stuffed Mushrooms Fritta

fried stuffed mushrooms w seafood parm


Calamari Fritti

arrabbiata sliced hot peppers or pomodoro


Breaded Chicken Cutlet

fried chicken cutlets w/Tomato Sauce Parmigiano

Fine dining on the water

Prix Fixe Menu Duo

Bucket of Balls

homemade meatballs in tomato sauce w/ cold ricotta cheese


Bucket of Balls & Links

homemade meatballs & sweet sausage in tomato sauce


Bucket of Spain

yellow rice, with chorizo sausage,chicken,shrimp,clams & mussels


Bucket of Anthony’s

chicken tenders w/ broccolini & mushrooms garlic & oil


Bucket of Jerk

tender dark chicken mushrooms & peppers marinated in a spicy sauce


Bucket of Pisa

tortellini smoked bacon w/ alfredo sauce shaved parmigiano


Bucket of Verdi

spinach raviolis homemade pomodoro sauce sliced parmigiano


Bucket of Wise Guy’s

homemade meat Sauce, fried eggplant, ricotta & fresh mozzarella


Bucket of Springer's

homemade Mix of Vegetarians tricolor tortellini w/filet of tom sauce

Fine Dining

PASTA’s ala Duo

Fusilli Pork and Peas

fusilli, w/applewood smoke bacon, onions, peas


Linguine with Clam sauce

linguine, w/ little neck clams, red or white & spicy


Penne Ala Vodka Hold off the Peas

prosciutto, onions, tomato cream


Pece” Linguine Marinara

shrimp, calamari, clams, mussels


Orecchietta Garlicy

sausage, broccoli rabe, garlic, e.v.o.o.

Fine Dining

SECONDI ala mono

Stuffed Chicken

stuffed with broccolini parmigiana


Braised Beef Short Rib

asparagus, mashed potatoes, demi glace


Eggplant Parmigiana

mozzarella, fried eggplant,Tomato reggiano


Chicken piccante

butter white wine, mozzarella, cherry peppers

Chicken Scarpariello

sausage, peppers, potatoes, onions

Steak Anthony’s 14oz. Rib Eye

cherry peppers, mushrooms, & potatoes


Frenched Chicken on the Bone

on the bone, olive oil, garlic, fresh herbs


Chicken Sorrentino

eggplant, prosciutto, mozzarella, marsala

Grilled Cut Chicken Breast

w/ fresh beefsteak tomato & mozzarella Vinaigrette

Bone Out Pork Ribs

cherry peppers, mushrooms, broccolini rabe &, potatoes

Fine Dining

PESCE ala mono

Filet of Sole Arreganatta Crumbs

broccoli rabe lemon & garlic & olive oil


Pan Seared Salmon Dijonnaise

dill sauce, mixed corn relish


Fried Shrimp Oreganata

linguine, garlic, olive oil


Stuffed Shrimp Scampi

saffron rice, lemon emulsion


Fried Shrimp and Fishes

flounder & crab fritters tri slaw & corn bread

Fine Dining

Desserts a La Mono

Cheesecake Juniors

Authentic Cheesecake Juniors in Brooklyn


Tiramisu Square’s With Lady Fingers

Tiramisu with Mascarpone Cheese with Ladies fingers


Lava Heat and Eat Strawberry or Blueberry Compote

Chocolate, Lava, Heat and Eat, Strawberry or Blueberry Compote


B & W Cannoli Choc dipped ½ & ½ B

B for Chocolate dipped & W White chocolate dipped Cannoli Choc ½ & ½ Moose and Canol

Fine Dining


Sautéed Broccoli Rabe


String Beans


Roasted Potatoes Italian Style

Baked Cauliflower


Parmigiano,Sautéed Broccoli Rabe & Sausage


Saute Broccolini

A candle light dinner on the water

Book a Table

Call today to a make reservations at 631-981-4242
or click to make online reservations

[contact-form-7 id="14" title="Reservation Form"]

planning an Event?

Contact us about planning your special family dinner or small event. 
Our private dinning room or Terrace Room is ideal for a family dinner or special event for 50 people and under parties.